|Benefit They're Real Push Up Liner|
Not that these are important but below are things that Benefit claims this liner does. ;)
After trying it a few times, I have to say this sucks lots. It's hard to use. I like the applicator but the liner itself is not fluid enough to create a smooth line. A smooth line requires going over the line multiple times. Even then it's not perfectly smooth. Also in the process, the line gets very thick, which I think would be fine for some people who like their liners thick anyway. But even so, it's hard to control the thickness. That means uneven liner. A big no no.
On top of that, it wears horribly. On me, it smudged AND flaked within a couple of hours. Interestingly enough, wearing a primer doesn't help. Also the swatches on my hand came off without a trace fairly easily with water and minimal rubbing so I wouldn't say it's waterproof.
The liner is very black and it smudges fairly well for a liner that is very dry. But that's not enough to make up for crappy aspects of the formula.
So my verdict on this liner is nice applicator, awful awful formula.